WATCH BOX OFFICE MOVIES FOR FREE
Why Detective Pikachu And Sonic The Hedgehog Are Taking Totally Different Approaches To Their Big Screen Movies
When the first trailer for Sonic the Hedgehog dropped late last month, the internet collectively imploded in a sea of threads, tweets and memes, all expressing confusion, frustration and horror at the look of the titular speedster. This live-action Sonic was not the video game icon that has been showing fans the meaning of speed since the early '90s; this was something else, and it had human teeth.
Not long after the Sonic the Hedgehog trailer came out, another video game icon hit theater screens. The Pokmon franchise finally made its live-action feature film debut, with the face of the franchise leading the charge in Detective Pikachu.
In addition to the fact that they are both video game movies, the proximity of the Sonic the Hedgehog trailer and the theatrical release of Detective Pikachu invite obvious comparisons. I am not the first to notice this, but I think it is worth discussing because even a surface-level look at both films reveals the totally different approaches Sonic the Hedgehog and Detective Pikachu are taking to their big screen movies.
Lets first look at Sonic the Hedgehog, the myriad ways the trailer confounded fans and what that says about the approach the film is taking.
Beyond the baffling trailer song choice and the changing of Sonics powers, the most obvious point of discussion was Sonics look in the new film. His overall proportions are quite different than his video game counterpart with limbs that are too muscular and a head and torso that are too small. What's more egregious, though, are Sonics facial features.
The film design eschews Sonics traditional uni-eye look, where one eyeball has two pupils for a more realistic smaller, two-eye aesthetic. The design choice that has gotten the most hate, though, has to be Sonics teeth, which look very human, a look that doesnt comport with the teeth of either his video game inspiration or the teeth of an actual hedgehog.
Whats especially fascinating about the reaction to Sonic's look in the trailer is that it was entirely predictable. When the first poster featuring Sonics silhouette was revealed last year, fans were immediately skeptical of the hedgehogs build. Complaints grew even louder when another poster showed Sonics eerily human and muscular legs.
I dont know if it was a feeling that they knew better or that the complainers were in the minority, but did anyone involved with the film, after seeing the criticism of the posters, really think Wait till they see the final design, theyre gonna love it!?
Speaking about the decision to change Sonics eyes for the movie, executive producer Tim Miller previously said:
I don't think SEGA was entirely happy with the eye decision, but these sorts of things you go, 'It's going to look weird if we don't do this.' But everything is a discussion, and that's kind of the goal, which is to only change what's necessary and stay true to the rest of it. He's not going to feel like a Pixar character would because I don't think that's the right aesthetic to make it feel like part of our world.
Those last words are quite telling, to make it feel like part of our world. All of these changes to this iconic video game character for his feature film debut speak to the approach on the part of the filmmakers to make Sonic the Hedgehog realistic.
Thats why Sonic has separate eyes and more human features, and why hes an alien in the film. Because the choice was made to set this film in our world as we know it. Sonic the Hedgehog isnt the first movie to take this approach when adapting a fantastical property to live-action (animation has more freedom to be strange in this regard). The Smurfs in 2011 and 1987s Masters of the Universe come to mind as properties that took characters out of their fantasy worlds and plopped them in our Earth.
The thinking behind this strategy (from my perspective anyways) is that it creates a smaller barrier of entry for the audience. Instead of trying to explain to moviegoers that the world of the film is one in which characters like Sonic exist, he is made into an alien and dropped into our world, where only he is different and everything else is familiar.
This approach also necessitates that Sonic look more realistic, or the filmmakers idea of realistic for an alien hedgehog. The concern being that if Sonic looks too cartoony or too Pixar-like, as a CGI character, he will stick out like a sore thumb and look, for lack of a better word, fake.
Its not an inherently bad approach and I have no doubt that everyone involved is working their hardest to make the best movie they can, one that also pleases fans of the character. But this approach of setting the story in our world and altering Sonics look, which was guaranteed to result in backlash, to fit into that world, speaks to a fundamental disconnect with the fans of this property and what people want from adaptations of iconic stories and characters.
Now contrast this with Detective Pikachu. Like Sonic the Hedgehog, Detective Pikachu is based on recognizable video game characters that fans have come to know and love over decades. And while I am sure that somewhere there are fans who have taken issue with the look of the Pokmon in the movie, there has been no major outcry because by and large they look pretty much exactly like their video game counterparts.
Pikachu looks like Pikachu; from his lightning bolt tail and his rosy cheeks to his weapons-grade cuteness, he looks like the Generation 1 electric-type rodent Pokmon that became the face of the brand. The same is true for Charizard, Gyarados, Psyduck, Cubone, Bulbasaur, Mewtwo and all the rest. The film embraced the iconic designs of these creatures and rendered them in an extremely faithful fashion.
The only real sort of overture towards realism Detective Pikachu makes is to give the Pokmon some texture to make them feel more tangible and less like flat cartoons. But that tactic does little to nothing to diminish their resemblance to their video game inspirations.
Detective Pikachu was able to do this and give us such great live-action Pokmon because the story didnt force things to take place in our world. Instead, the film took the approach that in the world of the film, Pokmon exist alongside humans. They arent aliens that just landed or genetic mutations or beasts from another dimension, they just are, and that premise required remarkably little in the way of world-building or expository setup.
The filmmakers trust that you know what Pokmon are, know what they look like and can wrap your head around a live-action world where they exist. There is no handholding and no timidity that audiences wont get it or will check out if the movie goes all in on Pokmon weirdness.
Its an approach that exudes a tremendous amount of confidence in the audience, trust in the characters and the story and faith in the source material. It either works or it doesnt. Detective Pikachu bravely asks you to buy in and that gamble seems to have worked.
While opinions may vary, despite not striving for realism in the Pokmon designs, Detective Pikachu does the one thing it had to, according to CinemaBlends Mike Reyes: it convinces you that Pokmon and humans can live together in a live-action cinematic world. Even though they look almost exactly like the Pocket Monsters in the video game, it doesnt take you out of the movie. More quantitative metrics also support the success of Detective Pikachus approach.
Rob Lettermans movie is the best-reviewed video game movie of all time and it also enjoyed a bigger opening weekend than any of its video game adaptation predecessors. Audiences gave it an A- CinemaScore and there certainly seems to be interest and potential for future Pokmon movies.
This isnt all to say that Detective Pikachus approach was unquestionably right and Sonic the Hedgehogs definitively wrong. Each property is different and adaptation is one of the most precarious forms of filmmaking. Sonic may well end up being a far better movie than Pikachu for all I know, and maybe going all in with a more fantastical world where Sonic exists wouldnt have worked.
Nevertheless, it is also important to remember that this isnt a literary adaptation. These arent only iconic characters, they have iconic designs, and I think it is telling that the highlight of the Sonic trailer, for me anyways, was at the end where Jim Carrey looks the most like his video game counterpart Dr. Robotnik.
To his credit, in response to the vocal criticism, Sonic the Hedgehogs director Jeff Fowler said that design changes to Sonic are coming. It's nice to know they're listening and fan sentiment can make a difference. But I cant help thinking that if this movie just took an approach that was less focused on realism and setting things in our world, and instead embraced the source material and trusted audiences to get it, the Blue Blur would be coming to the big screen surrounded by a spirit of excitement, not one of trepidation.
We'll find out how Sonic the Hedgehog is received by the public when it races into theaters on November 8, but for now you can still enjoy Detective Pikachu on the big screen.
The post itself is a tribute to Stan Lee and Jeremy Renner even offers a little bow of deference to him in the video. And if there was any doubt, Jeremy Renner makes it plain how he feels about Stan Lee with the video's caption.
When the latest entry into the Willy Wonka universe comes out — whenever that may fall — it'll look like nothing like any previous Wonka flick. According to Collider, the new movie will be a
Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory (1971) - Trivia - IMDb
Michael Caine Explains the End of 'Inception', but Should He Have? fall and once they realized Nolan wasn't going to tell them there was excitement and giddiness at the idea of the
Michael Caine explains the ending of Inception at Film4
Chris Hemsworth first met Thor: Ragnarok director Taika Waititi over lunch at a cafe. "It felt like a first date," the God of Thunder told Heat Vision on the carpet at the world premiere of the
Thor: Ragnarok Director Recently Met with Marvel, Was It
Last year, Ron Howard had mentioned that he's got an idea for a sequel to his 1988 fantasy adventure film Willow, and Warwick Davis had noted not long after Howard made his comments that Solo
Director Ron Howard Is Hoping to Make a Sequel to 'Williow
Two new Mission: Impossible films are in the works! Tom Cruise - who has played Ethan Hunt in all six movies in the franchise so far - confirmed the news on social media on Monday (January 14).
New Poster for 'Mission Impossible: Fallout' : movies
7 DC Characters Who Could Show Up In Wonder Woman 2
This news makes the score sound like it will be a co-composing between the Hans and Gary, making it likely to be a synth score which doesn't really work for a mythical character like Wonder Woman. 3. People enjoyed Rupert Gregson's attempt at a super hero score, so to seem him replaced already on the first sequel (while the themes may be
Why Hans Zimmer Is Done Writing Music For Superhero Movies
Subscribe To New Details On The New Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom Characters Updates seen at what looks like a dino auction in the trailer. Also playing an as-yet-unnamed and possibly the
Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom (2018) Download Torrent
We've still got a couple years to go, but Jennifer Lawrence easily deserves consideration in any debate about the decade's best movie star. In a shockingly short time, the actress has compiled
List of Jennifer Lawrence Movies Ranked From Best To Worst
One X-Men: Dark Phoenix Actor Is Down For A Spinoff
See more ideas about 50 shades darker, 50 shades freed and Fifty shades of grey.
Dakota Johnson and Jamie Dornan dance at their wedding
So Danny McBride's Crocodile Dundee 4 Is Actually Fake. That's not a movie. THIS is a movie. (Well, not really)
Danny McBride's "Dundee" Sequel Exposed as a Fake | ResetEra
While it's been rumored for years, it looks like an Obi-Wan movie isn't happening anytime soon. And Ewan McGregor has a great reason why. Subscribe To Why Ewan McGregor Is Confident The Obi-Wan
Star Wars: Ewan McGregor Is Certain An Obi-Wan Movie Won't
Avengers Infinity War fan event: Tom Hiddleston on WHY Loki hands Tesseract to Thanos AVENGERS INFINITY WAR screening a special preview to London fans while stars including Brits Tom Holland
what is the best movie streaming app for firestick
after full movie streaming
exodus movie streaming
how do movie streaming sites work
how much data would streaming a movie use
movie streaming killer
movie streaming industry
movie streaming vudu
how do movie streaming sites make money
moonlight movie streaming
movie streaming english free
movie streaming tagalog
free movie streaming sites
movie streaming app xbox one
movie streaming sites xbox one
top 10 movie streaming sites 2018
movie streaming v
movie streaming harry potter
movie streaming sites new zealand
best movie streaming sites free
movie streaming us
popcorn movie streaming
movie streaming market share
sully movie streaming
harry potter movie streaming
split movie streaming
x deal full movie streaming
kedarnath movie streaming
dilan 1990 full movie streaming
elf on the shelf movie streaming
movie streaming search
lego movie streaming youtube
youtube free movie streaming
movie streaming deals
best sites for movie streaming reddit
movie streaming links reddit
loro movie streaming
resolution movie streaming
dilan 1991 full movie streaming
yellow submarine movie streaming
movie streaming library
if looks could kill movie streaming
john wick 3 full movie streaming
how to watch movie streaming
movie streaming on firestick
live movie streaming sites
indonesian movie streaming online
movie streaming sites yahoo answers
movie streaming best websites
uri movie streaming partner
pengabdi setan 2017 full movie streaming
movie streaming gratis
free online movie streaming
vice movie streaming reddit
what are the best free movie streaming sites
movie streaming kingsman 2
i can only imagine full movie streaming
movie zone streaming
movie streaming yify
streaming movie kingsman
online hollywood movie streaming
the lego movie streaming
what is the best movie streaming site
www.free movie streaming
movie streaming with chromecast
xbox one movie streaming sites 2017
latest movie streaming sites
ex libris movie streaming
movie streaming bandwidth
movie streaming sites uk
glass movie streaming
kl special force full movie streaming
jumanji 2017 full movie streaming
veere di wedding full movie streaming
xbox one movie streaming sites
coco full movie streaming
movie streaming online reddit
john wick full movie streaming
inside out movie streaming
chinese movie streaming
movie streaming online sites
free online movie streaming australia
hong kong movie streaming
dilan full movie streaming
elf movie streaming netflix
best free movie streaming sites 2019
gifted movie streaming
movie streaming ita
movie streaming template free
rush movie streaming
clue movie streaming
movie streaming online for free
movie streaming template
danur 2 full movie streaming
movie streaming ps4
jelita sejuba full movie streaming online
movie streaming chromecast
online movie streaming app
joy movie streaming
kursk movie streaming
movie streaming english
rbg movie streaming
best free movie streaming app
can't help falling in love movie streaming
movie streaming greatest showman
movie streaming platforms
jumanji full movie streaming
free movie streaming app for ipad
movie streaming us free
must be love movie streaming
movie streaming programs
movie streaming hardwarezone
movie streaming uk sites
get out movie streaming
movie streaming pc
movie streaming urls
#Qesh #murica #blackiflix #FreeMovies #Filma #netflix #melanin #socialstreaming #merica #watchnerds #slay #birdbox #moviesstreaming #filmography #blacksuccess #Zgerdhiu #americanflag #filmlover #watchdose #TVSHow #Seriale #watchobsessed #funnytime #blacksocialmedia #watchswag #blacktech #watchthemoonrise #melaninmagic #sandrabullock #SomosTuConexi #watchblogger #getsome #Serialemetitrashqip #movieaddict #WatchMovies #filmyorumu #watchmvmt #watchluxus #america #Filma24 #CASAMXhostales #blackhistory365 #holiday #Filmametitrashqip #watchpornid #4thofjuly #filmizle #watchos4 #blackenterprise #watchquiz #WatchUsRise #movietime #watchbrandname #filmtavsiyesi #watchwomen #firecrackers #watchmovies #watchuswork #watchingthesunset #blackbusiness #hostales #TvSeries #netflixturkiye #WatchRoss #watchphoto #watchenthusiasts #watchcandy #independenceday #HostalCASAMXalameda #blackqueen #watchhill #Movies #watchfamily #saladetv #watchestyle #watchalert #fireworks #watchful #bff #watchmaniac #blavity #putitinreverseterry #watchtattoo #tvroomdesign #watchcrazy #WatchJunkie #blackking #fourthofjuly
0 comments:
Post a Comment